Dogs

by Andy Hirsch

Andy Hirsch’s Dogs uses a friendly mutt’s search for his favorite ball to guide readers through the science of dogs, including their ancestry, varied traits, and intelligence. Presented through lively comics and an imaginative canine guide, the book combines a fictional adventure with factual explanations of genetics, evolution, and domestication.

Big Idea

Dogs can look and behave very differently while sharing ancestry and many traits. Writers can make complex science accessible by connecting accurate explanations to a character’s curiosity, humor, and a familiar goal.

Discussion Questions

1.How does the mutt’s search for his ball help you stay interested in the scientific information? What might change if the book presented only facts?
2.A Chihuahua and a Saint Bernard look very different. What can their similarities and differences help us understand about dogs?
3.How would you explain the relationship between dogs and wolves without saying that a wolf simply turned into a pet?
4.What might count as evidence that a dog is intelligent? How might a dog show intelligence differently from a person?
5.Which moment helped you understand a difficult idea through pictures, words, or humor? How did those parts work together?

Lesson Plan

⏱ 45–50 minutes📦 Copies of or access to Dogs, paper, pencils, crayons or markers, four-panel comic templates, chart paper, and sticky notes

Learning Goals

Identify the difference between the book’s fictional framing adventure and its factual scientific explanations.
Describe one accurate idea about dog ancestry, inherited traits, or variation using grade-appropriate language.
Explain how panel sequence, dialogue, and visual details affect reading pace.
Create and revise a short comic that combines a character’s goal with a clear science explanation.

Activity Steps

1.Read selected passages showing the mutt’s ball-search adventure and a scientific explanation. Ask students to identify what belongs to the imagined story and what teaches real information.
2.Build a class fact bank from the reading, such as dogs sharing ancestry with ancient wolves or dogs varying in size and coat. Clarify that individual dogs do not evolve during their lifetimes; populations change across generations.
3.Model a four-panel sequence: a dog spots a ball, follows it, notices a contrasting dog, and shares a fact about their differences. Demonstrate how stretching one action across panels can slow the reading.
4.Have students plan and draw their own four-panel comics, including a clear goal, one checked fact, and a deliberate fast or slow moment. Younger students may dictate captions; older students can explain inherited variation more precisely.
5.Invite partners to read the comics aloud, pointing to each panel. Partners identify the science fact and describe where their reading sped up or slowed down.
6.Ask students to revise one caption, panel, or pause for clarity, then share how their change affected the reading experience.

Standards Connections

ELA: CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RI.1.7 — Use illustrations and details in a text to describe its key ideas; applicable to the book’s informational content.
ELA: CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.W.3.2 — Write informative/explanatory texts that develop a topic with facts and details; addressed through the comic’s science explanation.
ELA: CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.SL.2.1 — Participate in collaborative conversations with peers and adults.
Science: NGSS 3-LS3-1 — Analyze and interpret data to provide evidence that plants and animals inherit traits and that variation exists within similar organisms; this lesson introduces related concepts rather than fulfilling the full performance expectation.
Visual Arts: National Core Arts Standards, Creating — Organize and develop artistic ideas through sequential images and revise work using feedback.

Printable Teacher’s Guide

Take this lesson with you

Get the printable teacher’s guide for Dogs, including discussion questions, classroom activities, a Big Idea, and a writing prompt.

Create a Free Account

Grades K-5 Ready to print

Classroom Resources

Enjoy gamifying this read:

Pace-Write-Read Study with Pace-Write It!

Dogs offers a useful pacing study because it connects two kinds of forward motion: a mutt wants to find his ball, and readers want answers to questions about dogs. The familiar, playful goal gives young readers an entry point into less familiar ideas such as ancestry, genetics, and evolution. Although introduced here as a picture-book selection, the work’s science-comics format makes panels, speech balloons, and visual sequences especially important teaching tools. During a Pace-Write-Read study, invite students to notice when they follow action quickly and when they stop to examine an explanation or image. Avoid treating pace as simply the number of words: a detailed picture, a new science term, or a comparison between dogs can require more thinking time than a short action sequence. Read a selected sequence aloud twice, first briskly and then with purposeful pauses, and discuss which choices support understanding. Students can borrow the book’s broad craft approach without copying its artwork or wording: give a character a simple goal, introduce a genuine question, and use images and concise language to explore the answer. For K–2, emphasize oral storytelling, drawing, and one accurate observation; for grades 3–5, add explanations, source checking, and deliberate revisions to panel timing.

Element	How to notice or teach it in the novel
1. Pacing	Compare a ball-search sequence with a science explanation. Ask where readers move quickly and where vocabulary or visual information invites them to slow down.
2. Plot	Track the mutt’s search for his favorite ball as the framing plot. Discuss how this simple goal connects scientific topics that might otherwise feel separate.
3. Prosody	Read the canine guide’s speech with expression, then use a measured voice for a challenging explanation. Let students explain how phrasing and pauses help listeners distinguish excitement from information.
4. Word	Collect important words from the selected pages, especially terms related to ancestry, traits, and evolution. Practice replacing a confusing term with a brief explanation before returning to the scientific word.
5. Concept	Separate the big concept of change across generations from the familiar idea of an individual dog growing up. Have students explain the distinction with drawings or spoken sentences.
6. Voice & Worldview	Notice how a friendly canine guide makes science feel approachable. Discuss how curiosity about dogs encourages readers to see everyday animals as subjects worth investigating.
7. Point of View	Examine how following a dog’s interests changes the presentation of information. Rewrite a short explanation for a human scientist narrator and compare the effect.
8. Setting & Place	Track shifts between the ball-search adventure and visual presentations of scientific information. Ask which background details establish a place and which primarily help explain an idea.
9. Original Characters	Identify what makes the mutt an engaging guide beyond simply being a dog. Students can invent their own canine learner with a different goal, concern, or habit.
10. Dialogue	Study how speech balloons deliver personality and information together. Have students turn one fact from the reading into a brief exchange without sacrificing accuracy.
11. Details	Look for details that help distinguish dogs, such as relative size or coat appearance. Discuss which details support the scientific point and which build character or humor.
12. Descriptions	Compare what the pictures show about a dog with what the words explain. Challenge students to write a caption that adds useful information rather than merely naming what is visible.
13. Firsts	Study the reader’s first introduction to the canine guide and his goal. Ask what a new reader needs to understand immediately before encountering scientific explanations.
14. Immediacy & Engagement	Discuss why looking for a favorite ball is an easy goal to understand. Invite students to begin their comics with a visible want or action rather than a long introduction.
15. Story Scenes, Summaries & Structures	Distinguish moments that show an event unfolding from passages that compress scientific history or explain a process. Discuss why a book about evolution needs to move between these approaches.
16. Tension / Suspense / Surprise	Separate the small suspense of the missing ball from the curiosity created by scientific questions. Ask which kind of uncertainty most motivates students to keep reading.
17. Flashback, Flash-Forward, Cliffhanger	Treat explanations of canine ancestry as shifts into the past, distinguishing scientific history from a character’s personal memory. If a selected transition leaves a question unanswered, discuss its cliffhanger effect without assuming every transition uses one.
18. Page Turns and Chapter Breaks	Inspect an actual page turn or chapter boundary in your edition. Notice whether it completes an explanation, introduces a new question, or invites readers onward.
19. Pace & Creativity	Ask students to draw the same ball-chasing action in one panel and then three panels. Compare how the expanded version changes attention, anticipation, and reading time.
20. Play	Use the mutt’s interest in his ball to discuss how play can frame serious learning. Students can build a science question around a playful canine action.
21. Performance	Assign readers to voice speech balloons while another student points to the relevant visual information. Pause whenever listeners need time to inspect a picture.
22. Personality	Look for expressions, actions, and wording that reveal the mutt’s personality. Ask how those choices make an informational guide feel like a character rather than a textbook narrator.
23. Humor	Choose a moment students find funny and identify whether the humor comes from words, pictures, or their combination. Discuss how humor can refresh attention without replacing the explanation.
24. Pause	Identify a point where readers need to stop and process a scientific idea. Practice adding a silent beat before moving from the explanation back to the adventure.
25. Poetry / Poetic Devices	Do not assume the book uses verse or rhyme; instead, inspect selected language for sound patterns, comparisons, or vivid phrasing. Students may create an original alliterative dog caption as an extension.
26. Repetition	Track returns to the ball-search goal and discuss how a recurring concern helps orient readers. Distinguish this repeated story element from repeated scientific vocabulary used to support learning.
27. Rhythm	Listen to the rhythm created by alternating short speech turns and longer explanations. Have students test where a brief reaction can give readers a welcome break.
28. Punctuation	Inspect punctuation in selected speech balloons and read it aloud. Compare how a question mark, period, or exclamation point changes the canine speaker’s tone and timing.
29. Questions	Use questions about wolf ancestry, size differences, and intelligence as reasons to read closely. Ask students to distinguish questions the book answers from questions requiring further research.
30. Compare-Contrast	Use the Chihuahua–Saint Bernard contrast to examine differences within dogs. Pair visible differences with shared characteristics so that comparison does not become a list of differences alone.
31. Objects	Study the favorite ball as an object that gives the mutt a concrete goal. Ask how one familiar object can connect an adventure to a sequence of learning moments.
32. Threes	Check a selected sequence for any meaningful grouping of three rather than assuming a rule-of-three pattern. As an experiment, students can organize their own sequence into a question, an explanation, and a reaction.
33. Lists	Turn information from a selected explanation into a short list, then compare it with the comic presentation. Discuss what the list makes easier to scan and what personality or connections it loses.
34. White Space & Negative Space	Inspect spaces between panels and around text in your copy. Ask how separation helps readers follow order and avoid being overwhelmed by scientific information.
35. Art & Graphics	Choose a visual explanation and identify information supplied by the artwork rather than the wording alone. Discuss why scientific comics require readers to integrate both.
36. Interactives & Gamification	Create a classroom prediction game around the reading: students propose an answer to a dog-science question, then check it against the text. Present this as a teaching extension, not as a built-in book feature.
37. Placement	Trace the reading path through panels, speech balloons, and explanatory text. Ask how placing an image before or after an explanation affects what readers notice first.
38. Form	Discuss how the science-comics form accommodates both an invented canine adventure and factual content. Compare its possibilities with those of a prose report about dogs.
39. Dummy	Have students fold scrap paper into a miniature planning booklet, or dummy, for a dog-science comic. Test panel order and page turns before adding finished drawings.
40. Passion	Ask what makes the book’s interest in dogs feel enthusiastic and inviting. Encourage students to choose a dog question they genuinely care about while checking the accuracy of their answers.

Pace-Write It!

20-minute Pace-Write-It! task: One Ball, Two Speeds. Minutes 0–3: Revisit a short passage involving the mutt’s ball-search frame and recall one verified fact about dogs from the reading. Minutes 3–5: Model a two-panel comic in which an original dog chases a ball past two very different-looking dogs and shares that fact. Minutes 5–12: Students create two versions of the same event: a quick two-panel version and a slower four-panel version that adds observation, anticipation, or a reaction without changing the science. K–2 students may draw and dictate; grades 3–5 add concise captions explaining variation or ancestry. Minutes 12–17: Partners read both versions aloud, pointing to each panel and identifying what made one version take longer. Minutes 17–20: Students revise one panel or caption and complete the reflection, 'I changed the pace by ___, which helped my reader ___.'

Classroom Activities

Follow the Ball: A Dog-Science Comic

Students create a four-panel comic in which a fictional dog follows a bouncing ball and discovers one accurate fact about dogs. By making one action stretch across several panels, students explore how comic writers slow down an important moment while keeping a scientific explanation clear.

Create a free account to reveal this guide

Your free account includes three free resource downloads — teacher’s guides and Pace-Write-Read writing activities, with discussion questions and classroom activities included.

Create Free Account Sign in

Discussion questions PWR workshop PDF download